Best New York Personal Insurance Companies

In 1982, Jim Stone had a vision to form a new kind of auto insurance company that would create a higher standard of customer service. Plymouth Rock has been steadfast in our unique commit...

Since 1876, Central has evolved into a successful property and casualty group with combined assets over $1 billion. Central writes over 350,000 insurance policies for customers in 23 stat...

We are not a typical boating insurance company. Built for boaters by boaters, we have deep knowledge of both boating and insurance, which allows us to provide you an innovative policy tai...

Stillwater is a national personal and commercial lines carrier with rock-solid financial stability, ready to be there for life’s unexpected events. We understand that insurance can be com...

At PersonalUmbrella.com, your agent can get you a quote in minutes by answering only four simple questions — all without needing a signed application from you. Why choose PersonalUmbrella...

The Andover Companies has been providing quality insurance protection since 1828. We are committed to providing competitive, affordable products tailored to meet the needs of homeowners, ...

Travelers meets your personal insurance needs with a full line of products that include auto, home, boat, identity theft, umbrella, rental property, and wedding. Take a closer look at Tra...

We love New York – it’s why we’re based in CNY! But we also know that living in the Northeast comes with its own unique challenges. At NYCM Insurance, our team of over 900 employees is de...

Why choose Cinch Home Services? For the past 45 years, Cinch has been a leader in providing home solutions that protect against large out-of-pocket expenses due to home systems and applia...

As a specialty insurance company, Foremost® provides insurance choices that may not be offered by other companies. We've spent the last 65 years getting to know the markets we serve excep...

At Progressive, protecting what matters to you, matters to us. Progressive has grown into the #1 personal auto insurer through independent agents by delivering quality, affordable coverag...

We have been serving New York State residents for over 130 years. Our philosophy is simple yet effective and is centered on personal service and a commitment to our policyholders and prod...

Safeco has been protecting individuals and families with personal insurance coverage since 1923. With a comprehensive range of insurance coverage and expert advice from local independent ...

Providing peace of mind and financial stability to our policyholders before, during and after the unexpected occurs. Sterling Insurance is a highly respected, technologically advanced ins...